Recovery from "schizophrenia" and other "psychotic disorders"

I have written elsewhere about links between creativity and psychosis.  In a recent blog entry, Gianna Kali of “BeyondMeds” links to an article describing how teachers in schools all say they seek to encourage creativity, yet their favorite students all tend to be those who show traits incompatible with creativity – those who are good at agreeing, following rules, etc.  Why the discrepancy?  And what does it mean for mental health?

Creativity is extremely valuable, but it can also have high costs.  One of the costs is that people who are attempting to be creative will sometimes make errors, and their attempted improvements will sometimes make things worse.  But if we are to become a society that truly values creativity, we need to recognize that we benefit from those who live more “on the edge” and who sometimes fall off the edge:  instead of stigmatizing them or labeling them as forever ill, we might better collaborate with them in helping them figure out where they might have gone wrong while also staying open to the possibility they have a lot to teach us.

I really wonder how much creative talent is currently buried under high doses of antipsychotic medications……

In the attempt to convince people to take medications, the hazards of such medications are often minimized or overlooked. While many people may truly be better off taking some medications, at least for awhile, the danger in hiding the hazards of the drugs is that rational decisions about how long to stay on medications, at what dosage, and how hard to try to find alternatives, become impossible. Instead, an illusion is created that the only rational approach is to stay on medications indefinitely, because only an irrational person would risk the return of a destructive psychosis.

If we really allowed ourselves to face all the facts however, we would see that these decisions are much more complex. For example, while the effects of being caught up in psychosis can be terrible, the effects of the antipsychotic medications can be terrible as well. These medications significantly increase the risk of death, due to causing things like heart problems, metabolic syndrome, obesity, diabetes etc. And, while most of psychiatry is still in denial about it, it appears that antipsychotic medications have a tendency to shrink brains. (For those of you unfamiliar with the evidence for this effect, I include some references and other information at the end of this post.)

Some people might think that if antipsychotic medications will shrink the consumer’s brain and then possibly kill them, then the obvious decision is to just get off the medications as quickly as possible. However, the problem is that it appears that uncontrolled psychosis, and its associated distress, will also shrink a person’s brain and very possibly kill them (besides making a total mess of their life in other ways.) More »